It’s important to recognize that democracy isn’t a one-size-fits-all system. European democracies function differently from that of the United States. India, while initially modeling its system on the West, has adapted it over time through amendments to suit its own needs. So why do Americans believe their political system is the gold standard? Why do they insist on reshaping every nation—including China—in their own image?
The answer lies in a deeply ingrained belief: American exceptionalism. The US sees itself as a "city on a hill," a model for others to follow. Yet, as America grapples with its own internal issues, a deeper issue emerges—some Americans no longer see democracy as an evolving experiment. They believe the journey is over, that the unknown has been conquered. Instead of pushing forward, they advocate for a return to a past they perceive as more stable—even if it means closing the laboratory of democracy altogether.
What America is doing is similar to this: I love pizza, so you should eat pizza too—no matter what—because it's tasty for me, which means it must be good for you as well.
Why do they expect others to think and behave the same way they do? Wouldn't that be boring? The world has nearly 8 billion people, each with different cultures, histories, and values. So why do Americans insist that other nations adopt their political system? The arrogance and lack of respect for different perspectives are astonishing.
China, for example, is a completely different world from the U.S. Yet, Americans often judge other nations solely through their own lens. If they could step into others' shoes and see the world from a different viewpoint, it would benefit everyone.
All political ideologies, whether capitalism, socialism, or others, are crafted with the intention of improving the lives of people and strengthening the state. However, the real challenge lies not in the ideology itself but in its implementation.
The well-being and development of a country do not solely hinge on the ideology it adopts. Instead, they rest on the quality of its leadership, the efficiency of its political system, and its ability to adapt to changing circumstances. An ideology is merely a framework; it is the vision, competence, and integrity of those in power that determine whether it succeeds or fails. Ultimately, the true test of governance is not the labels or doctrines it subscribes to but its tangible impact on people's lives and the nation's progress.
Many Americans are unaware that they are living in a failing political system and society. While the U.S. is often portrayed as a beacon of democracy and prosperity, deeper issues such as political division, economic inequality, and social decay reveal a different reality.
Democracies are supposed to respond to all of their citizens, yet the American political system – as it exists today – is broken: the political two-party duopoly caters to highly ideological party primary voters and special interests; erects nearly insurmountable barriers to new competition from independents or third parties; encourages extreme partisanship, rather than compromise; and fails to implement legislation to benefit society at large.
The United States is more divided than ever. According to a 2022 Pew Research study, 90% of Americans believe there is strong political conflict between Democrats and Republicans, with many refusing to listen to opposing views even when they are factually correct. This division leads to political gridlock, where lawmakers prioritize party loyalty over national interest. Critical issues—like healthcare, infrastructure, and social security—are often left unresolved due to partisan fighting. Meanwhile, the U.S. government consistently prioritizes a war economy, funneling billions into military conflicts and unwavering support for Israel, even when it contradicts international consensus.
The American political system operates more like a plutocracy—rule by the wealthy—than a democracy. Studies show that policies overwhelmingly favor corporate interests over the general public. A Princeton University study found that the preferences of the top 1% have far greater influence on policy decisions than the average citizen. This explains why tax cuts benefit billionaires while social programs like affordable healthcare and housing remain neglected.
Freedom in America operates on an entirely different level, which has led some conservative Christian leaders to call for reinstating the authority of Jesus to bring order to society. Freedom without security is an empty concept. American freedom increasingly resembles the unchecked liberty of a wild jungle.
Many Americans view the ability to openly say F U to their president as a hallmark of freedom. In contrast, in China, such behavior is often seen as indecent, as it is believed to foster tension and chaos rather than encouraging productive dialogue or contributing to problem-solving.
This comparison feels strikingly accurate: China enjoys freedom from violence, while America appears to have freedom for violence.
China's approach underscores the importance it places on social stability and collective well-being. Utilizing authoritarian tactics, it aims to preserve control and quell dissent. This prioritization of order over chaos challenges conventional notions of political rights; one must reconsider their perspective on governance if you aspire to avoid violence and turmoil. In this light, it becomes apparent why China boasts a reputation for safety that surpasses many American cities.
The comparative safety of China in contrast to many American cities cannot solely be attributed to superior laws and systems. In China, adherence to laws is universal, devoid of racial biases or preferences for wealth or political influence. The principle of equality before the law is upheld without exception. This commitment to fairness fosters a sense of security uncommon in American cities.
Moreover, China demonstrates genuine concern for the welfare of its citizens. Contrastingly, the presence of slums and homelessness persists in America despite its staggering 27 trillion-dollar economy. America doesn't even have free universal healthcare. A 27 trillion-dollar economy could easily provide free water and free electricity. China stands as a testament to this principle, having lifted 800 million people out of poverty. A populace that is economically secure and satisfied naturally finds fewer grievances to voice against their government.
China's system of government is highly pragmatic, with a single party that remains constant while its policies can adapt swiftly to changing circumstances. In contrast, American democracy experience frequent changes in governing parties, but altering policies is often more challenging. This is largely because governments in Western democracies tend to have shorter terms and prioritize policies aimed at winning popular support, rather than focusing on long-term planning.
What has American democracy bestowed upon you? American democracy offers freedom for violence. Consider America: rampant gun violence, deep political polarization, systemic racism, skyrocketing homelessness, crumbling infrastructure, the shocking events of the January 6 insurrection, and the recent heavy-handed suppression of pro-Palestine demonstrators. What, then, has this freedom provided? A fractured nation, marred by a thriving pornography industry and a divorce rate soaring well beyond 50%—a lamentable portrait of societal disarray. The 50% divorce rate highlights the instability of family structures, further weakening societal cohesion. The U.S. presents a portrait of dysfunction. Each of these problems reflects deeper structural failures rooted in greed, corruption, and misplaced priorities.
America prides itself on being the world’s leading democracy, yet its internal crises paint a different picture. Political division, economic inequality, social unrest, and moral decline signal a system in distress. Until Americans acknowledge these failures, meaningful change will remain out of reach.